| 1 | Compare cleansing performance | Removal of everyday makeup versus long-wear or water-resistant makeup; cleansing consistency; visible residue; and the number of wipes used in the test. | A documented test protocol stating the makeup types, application method, wiping procedure, evaluation criteria, and test conditions. | Compare products tested under the same conditions. Avoid treating an unspecified “removes makeup” claim as proof of performance on every formula. |
| 2 | Review the ingredient information | Full ingredient list, cleansing agents, preservatives, fragrance, and any ingredients relevant to the intended market or consumer group. | Current ingredient documentation using the naming format accepted in the target market, plus supporting product and safety documentation where required. | Check ingredient-list requirements country by country. A formula suitable for one market is not automatically compliant in another. |
| 3 | Check claims for substantiation | Claims such as “gentle,” “for sensitive skin,” “dermatologically tested,” or “ophthalmologically tested.” | Relevant test reports that describe the method, sample group, conditions, and the exact claim supported. | Testing language alone does not guarantee that a product will suit every user. Confirm that the evidence supports the wording used on the package and in advertising. |
| 4 | Assess wipe material and durability | Substrate composition, texture, thickness, absorbency, linting, and resistance to tearing during use. | Material specifications and test results for properties relevant to the product’s intended use. | Check whether material or sustainability claims are specific and substantiated. Do not assume that a wipe is biodegradable or compostable based on appearance alone. |
| 5 | Evaluate fragrance and eye-area suitability | Whether the product is fragranced, how eye-area use is described, and what precautions or directions appear on the label. | Formula details, appropriate safety assessment, and test evidence for any specific eye-area or fragrance-related claim. | Match the product’s intended use and directions to the needs of the target market. Avoid assuming that “fragrance-free” or “tested” means irritation is impossible. |
| 6 | Inspect packaging and shelf-life details | Reseal performance, moisture retention after opening, pack count, storage instructions, and product dating or durability information. | Packaging specifications and stability or compatibility information relevant to the finished product and pack format. | Check that the closure is practical for repeated use and that required labeling details are clear for the destination market. |
| 7 | Verify market-specific compliance | Applicable cosmetic rules, labeling language, ingredient restrictions, warnings, and environmental or disposal claims in each destination. | Market-specific regulatory review and claim support for the finished product, packaging, and sales materials. | Requirements vary by jurisdiction. Treat “flushable” and similar disposal claims with particular care, and provide disposal instructions appropriate to local rules and wastewater systems. |